Best Crib Mattresses: 5 Organic Options

A baby lays on an organic crib mattress and sleeps

Where your baby lays their head to sleep at night matters. Not only does it need to be comfortable and secure, but it also needs to be breathable, lightweight, and firm enough to support a growing body. We’ve got the product picks you need to keep your little one safe and sound. Let’s look at some of the best crib mattress product finds on the market as of 2024!


Jump To Our Picks


What is an Organic Crib Mattress?

Broadly speaking, an organic crib mattress is any mattress brands develop for babies or toddlers with organic materials. So that we consider a mattress organic, a textile must come from certain circumstances. For instance, the providers of cotton plants can’t use harmful pesticides while growing. 

So, when you shop organic, you likely get a higher-quality and wholesome version of your products. That is, organic items are generally safer, more natural, and more likely to have sustainability in mind. 

Top 5 Best Crib Mattress Finds: How We Chose

As we scoured the market for the best crib mattresses, we had a few important priorities in mind:

  • Organic, eco-friendly, non-toxic materials. We looked for top-rated items in terms of quality and safety. That means being certified organic, using natural materials, and also carefully designing products to support the needs of growing children.
  • Sustainable design. If it’s not made to last, it’s not worth the money. We found products that are made with sustainable materials and are durable enough to last for years.
  • Brand reputation. We gave extra consideration to items from brands we know are committed to our values, including sustainability, ethical production, and also transparency. 

Without further ado, let’s dive into our picks!

Our Picks


All featured products are chosen at the discretion of the author and DGHQ editors. However, Do Good HQ may make a small affiliate commission if you click through and make a purchase.



1. Naturepedic Breathable Organic Mini Crib Mattress

Experience ultimate safety and comfort with the Naturepedic Breathable Organic Mini Crib Mattress, crafted from eco-friendly materials for your baby's best sleep
CertificationsGOTS, MADE SAFE® Certified, UL/GREENGUARD, Environmental Working Group (EWG) Verified
MaterialsOrganic cotton fill and fabric, non-GMO sugarcane-based waterproof coating, PLA fiber, steel fasteners
Dimensions23.5” x 37.5” x 3”
Price at Publishing$279

Naturepedic’s breathable organic cotton crib mattress is a favorite for many reasons: it’s handcrafted, reasonably priced, and also made with only the best of the best materials. 

Highlights

Skilled Amish craftsmen carefully construct each Naturepedic mattress with responsibly sourced and also certified organic materials. We love that this item comes with an additional breathable cover that meets the same standards. 

Naturepedic itself is also a great brand to support. It’s a 1% for the Planet member and has earned an EWG VERIFIED® distinction for its packaging system, which helps keep 55,000 pounds of single-use plastics out of landfills annually.  

Things to Consider

Your investment is protected by a lifetime limited warranty to give you peace of mind. If you’re not sure whether this mattress is the right fit, try it for 100 nights for free – if you don’t love it, you can send it back to get a refund. 


2. Avocado Organic Crib Mattress

Give your baby the gift of natural comfort and support with the Avocado Organic Crib Mattress, made from eco-friendly materials for a healthy sleep environment.
CertificationsGOTS, GOLS, MADE SAFE, UL/GREENGUARD Gold, Climate Neutral, FSC
MaterialsOrganic cotton, wool, latex
Dimensions28” x 52” x 5.5”
Price at Publishing$395

It’s hard not to point to Avocado’s organic wool crib mattress as one of the best on the market; it even has a dual-sided design that can support your little ones from their infant through toddler years. 

Highlights

Each side of this crib mattress offers a different firmness level so that it can adequately support your child as they grow. That means years of enjoyment and sleeping on a cloud of organic wool and cotton. Both of these materials are breathable, soft, and temperature-regulating, helping babies stay warm on chilly nights and cool on warm ones. 

We also appreciate that this mattress doesn’t have any PVC or polyurethane foams, so it doesn’t rely on nonrenewable resources to offer comfort. 

Things to Consider

Each Organic Crib Mattress comes with a 25-year limited warranty and also a 30-night trial, which begins after you receive your order. 


3. Saatva Crib Mattress

Ensure your baby's restful sleep with the Saatva Crib Mattress, combining organic materials and superior support for a healthy, comfortable sleep environment.
CertificationsGOTS, GREENGUARD Gold, Cradle to Cradle Gold
MaterialsOrganic wool, organic cotton, natural latex, recycled steel coils
Dimensions28” x 52” x 6”
Price at Publishing$355

Say goodbye to traditional mattress materials entirely with this product find from Saatva. The brand’s organic wool and cotton mattress offers an extra-firm side for babies and also a firm side for toddlers.

Highlights

In addition to certified organic cotton and wool, this mattress utilizes natural latex to offer buoyancy and pressure-free support. Saatva uses a washing process to remove all allergy-causing proteins from its latex. That means that even the most sensitive systems will get protection from irritation. 

Things to Consider

Saatva’s got you covered with a lifetime warranty for this mattress, so you can splurge without fear of investing in something that ultimately disappoints. 


4. Sealy Airy Night Antimicrobial Diamond 2-Stage Crib Mattress

Provide your baby with a breathable and hygienic sleep on the Sealy Airy Night Antimicrobial Diamond 2-Stage Crib Mattress, designed for lasting comfort and protection.
CertificationsGREENGUARD Gold
MaterialsPolyester and blended fiber, cotton, rayon from bamboo
Dimensions28” x 52” x 6”
Price at Publishing$119

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option, you can’t go wrong with the Sealy Airy Night Diamond. This cotton, polyester, and bamboo crib mattress ticks all the right boxes, including breathability, antibacterial surfaces, and also years worth of comfort. 

Highlights

This is another two-sided mattress with different firmness levels to support children as they age. It also comes with a waterproof cover made of rayon from bamboo, which will keep your little one cool, safe, and sound all night long. 

Things to Consider

It’s worth noting that this mattress only comes with a one-year warranty, which is fairly low, in our opinion. It may be more affordable, but this mattress might not be as long-lasting as some of our other picks.


5. Next Best Option: Newton Baby Original Crib Mattress

Enjoy peace of mind with the Newton Baby Original Crib Mattress, offering unmatched breathability and safety for your baby's best sleep.
CertificationsUL/GREENGUARD Gold
MaterialsPolyester, food-grade polymer core
Dimensions52” x 28” x 5.5”
Price at Publishing$299.99

While this isn’t completely from organic materials, this recyclable crib mattress from Newton Baby deserves an honorable mention. The mattress is fully washable and also recyclable – that’s right, you can toss the whole thing in your washing machine!

Highlights

This mattress is super easy to clean and made to last. It’s lead- and phthalate-free and features a two-stage design, so you can feel confident about its longevity. Since it’s washable, it features no foam, latex, glue, or springs, giving your baby a totally clean and hypoallergenic sleep. 

Things to Consider

Enjoy Newton’s risk-free, 100-night trial to see how this mattress works for your space. You can also take advantage of its limited lifetime warranty, and you can make exchanges or upgrades within 30 days of purchase. 


How to Choose a Non-Toxic Crib Mattress You & Baby Will Love

Here are a few key points to keep in mind as you shop for the best crib mattress for your home and also your preferences:

  • Does your baby have any sensitivities? Each of our finds uses hypoallergenic materials and also unique design choices to ensure that they don’t expose your little ones to anything harmful.
  • Do you need a bed that grows with your child? If so, you’ll definitely want to opt for a two-sided product. 

Happy mattress shopping!

Featured image via Naturepedic

About The Author

Scroll to Top