The Best Organic Mattress Toppers: Our 5 Picks

Few things are worse than waking up to a sore back and stiff muscles. A mattress topper can help you sleep comfortably and deeply. But for the environmentally-conscious shopper, it can be hard to find options that are as kind to the planet as they are to your back. We’ve got our top five best organic mattress toppers to help you find the ideal fit for your lifestyle. Let’s dive into what you need to know to get started.

Jump To Our Picks

What Are Organic Mattress Toppers, Exactly?

As the name likely implies, an organic mattress topper is a pad made from materials that have been grown and processed without harmful chemicals, pesticides, or genetically modified organisms (GMOs).

In other words, a mattress topper that’s organic has to be made from materials that are organic, too. To be organic, a product must be raised sustainably and without exposure to synthetic materials.

Health- and environmentally-conscious shoppers seek out organic mattress toppers because they’re great for the planet and for the body. As the market becomes more congested with cheap, quickly-produced products, options that will last and are made well become increasingly attractive to consumers.

A good organic mattress topper can help you sleep better and more comfortably. But first, you’ll need to find the right one for your sleep style and preferences.

Top 5 Organic Mattress Toppers: How We Chose

There are many organic mattress toppers out there, but we’ve selected only the best of the bunch. We looked for material quality, user reviews, organic certifications, and overall value as we compiled this list of the best organic mattress toppers.

These picks give you the best bang for your buck and are created using only the finest materials and manufacturing processes. Only mattress toppers that are made without artificial or filler materials made this list. We also steered clear of products that don’t meet our quality expectations. When you shop for an organic mattress topper, you should find a product that will last you a long time.

With that said, we’ve got the rundown on the best mattress toppers for any sleep style or budget. Let’s take a closer look.

Our Picks

All featured products are chosen at the discretion of the author and DGHQ editors. However, Do Good HQ may make a small affiliate commission if you click through and make a purchase.

1. Avocado Eco Organic Mattress Topper

IThis approachable organic latex mattress topper from Avocado is wrapped in a breathable, organic cotton cover for an oh-so-comfortable experience. The topper is great for cool and contoured support, making it an ideal choice for side sleepers.

Highlights

Not only do you get a high-quality mattress topper when you shop with Avocado, but you also receive a durable topper cover that will protect your investment. Avocado is a leading brand in the eco-friendly niche and is well-known for reliable and sustainable products.

Things to Consider

While this topper is a popular choice, it doesn’t offer any sort of customization as other options do. Still, Avocado offers a one-year limited warranty for all purchases and a 100-night sleep trial policy. If you decide your mattress topper isn’t a good fit in the first 100 nights, you can return it and receive a full refund.

2. Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper

This Birch organic mattress topper is designed to maximize airflow and provide a great night’s sleep. It’s a fantastic way to make a bed that’s too hard more comfortable. Natural and organic materials join forces to create a durable yet breathable topper that will last for years to come.

Highlights

Birch products are handmade with care in the U.S., so you know your money is going toward local and sustainable manufacturing efforts. Plus, this topper ships in just three to 10 days; when you shop with Birch, the best night’s sleep you’ve had is just a few days away.

Things to Consider

As a higher-end product, the Birch organic mattress topper is a bit on the pricier side. But consumers seem to think it’s well worth the price tag; reviews praise the topper’s ability to ease pressure on sore joints and stiff muscles. Birch does offer a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty, so you can rest assured your money won’t go to waste.

3. Coyuchi Organic Cotton Mattress Pad

This simple organic cotton mattress pad is an attractive option for those looking for a great deal. It’s not a firm mattress topper but a soft, quilted pad that covers your bed like a fitted sheet.

Highlights

Customers love this mattress topper’s breathability. It’s one of the few options on the market that seems to truly keep users cool as they sleep at night, thanks to its 100% cotton composition. It’s also a more affordable option that’s generally easier to care for.

Things to Consider

While this topper is breathable, it’s not as sturdy as other options and likely won’t do as good a job softening an especially tough mattress. 

However, all Coyuchi orders are packed and shipped using sustainable methods, and orders over $300 qualify for free ground shipping. The brand also offers free returns within 30 days of purchase for a full refund.

4. PlushBeds Organic Mattress Topper with Quilted Organic Cover

This fan-favorite option from PlushBeds comes in two different thicknesses and firmness levels to offer the right fit for any sleeper. The pad itself is made of organic latex and is surrounded by a thick layer of organic wool. A soft, quilted organic cotton cover tops things off for a result that helps regulate temperature and cradles your body.

Highlights

According to PlushBeds, this organic mattress topper is ideal for side sleepers under 250 pounds. Those who fall outside this weight class can still enjoy the topper’s ability to add some softness and support to firm mattresses.

Things to Consider

PlushBeds organic latex mattress toppers come with a five-year warranty, but the brand reports their lifespan can last up to 20 years. PlushBeds does not offer a return policy, unlike other brands, and you can only cancel your order before your topper ships. So this option likely isn’t the way to go if you’re not sure which topper is right for you – once you buy it, it’s yours.

5. Silk & Snow Organic Mattress Topper

Silk & Snow delivers another quality product with this organic mattress topper, which comes in two different firmness options. We love this pick because it’s more affordable than other options but still comes with a cover and produces reliable results.

Highlights

The Silk & Snow organic mattress topper comes with its own cotton cover, which gives you more value for your purchase right off the bat. It’s also one of the few options that allow you to choose your firmness, which means more people can find a fit that works for them.

Things to Consider

Take advantage of Silk & Snow’s 100-night sleep trial to get a feel for whether this topper is right for you. All mattress toppers come with a three-year warranty for their latex layer and a one-year warranty for their cover.

Next Best Option for Price-Conscious Shoppers

Can’t swing an organic mattress topper but still want to shop for reliable and sustainable products? We’ve got you covered with our next best option: the Parachute Down Alternative Mattress Topper.

We love this mattress topper for a few key reasons: it’s sustainable, budget-friendly, and high-quality. Happy customers describe its consistency as marshmallow-like. Its hypoallergenic down alternative filler provides plenty of comfort and cushioning to support your body. Since it’s made entirely from cotton, it’s breathable enough to keep you cool all night long.

While this option might not be organic, it can still be considered an environmentally friendly choice. It’s made from natural and hypoallergenic ingredients and is durable enough to last many years, which ultimately helps you avoid buying multiple products that go to waste.

How to Choose an Organic Mattress Topper

With so many strong options to choose from, how can you make sure the mattress topper you choose is best for you? Look out for these key details as you make a decision for the best results.

• Materials: Most organic mattress toppers are made from latex, cotton, wool, or a combination of the three. Each material type has its perks; cotton, for instance, is very lightweight and breathable. Pick the best material for your needs, or opt for a blend to experience the best of both worlds.
• Size: Mattress toppers come in different sizes to fit mattresses of all kinds. Some might not be suited to thick or thin mattresses, depending on their fit, so be sure to consider how the topper will work with your bed before you make a purchase.
• Certifications: Look for organic certifications like GOTS and GOLS, which are international standards for organic materials. Products that tick these boxes follow all the right regulations to ensure they’re sustainably raised. 
• Manufacturing: Many options are manufactured in the U.S., which helps you support local economies and fair labor practices. Others are made overseas. Look for manufacturer details to get a feel for how ethically your mattress topper was produced. 
• Mattress Type: If you have a firm mattress, you’ll probably want to opt for a topper that’s a bit soft. The same goes for soft mattresses and firm toppers. Look for a mattress topper that will complement your mattress type and meshes with your sleep-related needs.

No matter what, take your time when selecting your dream organic mattress topper. It’s an investment you almost certainly won’t regret!