The Best Wool Mattress Topper: Our 6 Favorite Products
When it’s time to hit the sheets, the last thing you want on your mind is discomfort. Too hot, too cold, too firm, too soft – there are dozens of problems you might have with your mattress, but many of them can be addressed with a wool mattress topper. Check out these top picks to find the topper that’s right for your home.
What is a Wool Mattress Topper? Why Get One?
Wool mattress toppers are usually pads or fitted toppers that are designed to be layered between a mattress and fitted sheets. These toppers offer extra support and comfort to beds that might not be as comfortable as they could be.
In the case of wool toppers, temperature control and relief from allergy symptoms are also huge perks. Wool is great for keeping you comfortable year-round, making it a popular choice for shoppers looking for long-lasting and versatile bedding options.
Top 6 Wool Mattress Toppers: How We Chose
We looked for only the best of the best wool mattress toppers on the market to compile this list of picks so that you don’t have to. To select our favorites, we looked at a few key factors:
- Quality: How “good” the product is. Based on things like materials, manufacturing practices, craftsmanship, etc.
- Customer Experiences: How customers feel about the product. We looked at customer feedback and reviews to get a sense of how products perform over time.
- Brand: How the brand or manufacturer stacks up. We want to uplift brands that give back in some way, whether through their sustainable practices or commitment to customer satisfaction.
- Value: How the product matches its price. If you’re going to pay big, you deserve big results – and if the product doesn’t deliver, it’s simply not worth it.
Each pick below scores well in each category. Let’s take a closer look!
Our Picks
All featured products are chosen at the discretion of the author and DGHQ editors. However, Do Good HQ may make a small affiliate commission if you click through and make a purchase.
1. PlushBeds Natural Wool Mattress Topper
| Organic Certifications | GOTS, eco-INSTITUT, GREENGUARD Gold |
| Material | Virgin wool, GOTS-certified organic cotton |
| Thickness | 3 inches |
| Firmness | Soft, springy |
In our opinion, the best plush wool mattress topper comes from – big surprise – none other than PlushBeds! This natural wool mattress topper is made from ethically sourced ingredients that you can be proud of.
PlushBeds is a leading brand for sustainable home products, and this matter topper fits right into their top-notch product line. We love its supportive and cushiony feel, which embraces you like a cloud each time you lie down.
Highlights
This topper is a bit of an investment, but it’s worth every penny. Each PlushBeds wool topper is hand-tufted and made to order in California. The toppers are hypoallergenic, cruelty-free, and safe for even the most sensitive skin.
Fans of this option love its ability to keep them warm in the winter and cool in the summer. Its breathable fibers allow you to sleep peacefully no matter how you prefer to rest.
Things to Consider
PlushBeds offers a one-year warranty for this and other products. If your mattress topper doesn’t hold up during that time, you may be able to receive a refund or replacement. However, PlushBeds does not accept product returns. Given that this topper is on the pricier end, this con may be worth paying attention to.
2. The Wooly Mattress Topper by Woolroom
| Organic Certifications | N/A |
| Material | Wool, natural merino, natural viscose, organic cotton |
| Thickness | 3-4 inches |
| Firmness | Soft-Medium |
This Woolroom mattress topper is the perfect choice if you need a topper with moderate support and serious cushioning. Its thick layer of wool filling and micro coils make it sturdy enough to be like a mattress of its own! Plus, its ingredients are sustainably sourced and even flame-retardant.
Highlights
Woolroom leads by example with this topper by using only fully traceable British wool in its filling. All toppers are handcrafted in the U.S. and are completely free of latex, foam, synthetic materials, and glues.
Things to Consider
The Wooly Mattress Topper is one of few products with a long-term warranty. Your topper is covered by Woolroom for up to 10 years after purchase.
The brand also offers a 100-night sleep trial when you purchase your topper with one of their deluxe or organic mattress protectors. So, if you need to stock up on bedding, this pick might be a great deal for more reasons than one!
3. Coyuchi Climate Beneficial Wool Mattress Topper
| Organic Certifications | GOTS |
| Material | Climate Beneficial wool, GOTS-certified organic cotton |
| Thickness | Approx. 1 inch |
| Firmness | Soft |
If you want to give back to the planet, this Coyuchi mattress topper made from the brand’s Climate Beneficial wool for you. According to Coyuchi, the practices used to source and create the toppers help rebalance the carbon cycle. In other words, Coyuchi uses manufacturing processes that help offset or balance carbon emissions that contribute to climate change. Simply put: when you purchase this topper, you’re supporting sustainable business practices that truly make a difference.
Highlights
We love that this mattress topper is not only eco-conscious but also hypoallergenic and incredibly resilient. The soft wool hand-knotted into individual nine-inch squares is surrounded by premium organic cotton, which creates a soft and breathable result.
The topper also comes with four straps that secure around mattress corners and make it simple to keep your product in place.
Things to Consider
Coyuchi makes shopping for your dream wool mattress topper risk-free, at least for the first 30 days. During this time, you can send your topper back and receive a full refund. After your 30 days are up, you may still be eligible for an exchange or store credit for up to 365 past your purchase.
4. Avocado Luxury Alpaca Wool Mattress Topper
| Organic Certifications | GOTS, GREENGUARD Gold |
| Material | Alpaca fiber, GOTS-certified organic wool & cotton |
| Thickness | 2 inches or more |
| Firmness | Medium-Firm |
Avocado is back with another winner with this organic wool mattress topper, which comes in a Standard and Luxury Plush version. We’ll focus on the Standard version, which is the more price-conscious and popular of the two.
This topper offers a firmer feel than many of our other picks, potentially making it a top choice for side sleepers, back sleepers, and those with chronic pain.
It’s also a bit heavier than some of the other options out there, but its cotton outer layer ensures it’s still breathable. Plus, four elastic straps are attached to keep your topper from sliding around while you sleep.
Highlights
Avocado’s wool mattress toppers are handcrafted with ethically sourced alpaca fiber and GOTS-certified organic wool. They’re certainly thicker and sturdier than many competing products, thanks to the high-performing fabrics used in their design. We know Avocado as a brand committed to safe, sustainable products, so we trust this topper is created with care.
Things to Consider
If you want to test out Avocado’s organic wool mattress topper, take advantage of the brand’s 30-day sleep trial. The product comes with a one-year limited warranty, which isn’t as high as we’d like to see for an option in this price range. Still, the opportunity to try before you fully commit makes this pick worth it overall.
5. Boll & Branch Mattress Topper
| Organic Certifications | GOTS, STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX |
| Material | Wool, cotton, poly blend |
| Thickness | 2 inches |
| Firmness | Soft |
If pillowy is the name of your game, this luxurious wool mattress topper is sure to impress. It’s designed to offer cloud-like comfort with layers of wool, cotton, and poly blend wrapped in a breathable soft outer shell.
Highlights
We appreciate that this Boll & Branch piece features humanely sourced wool and high-quality cotton. The softness this topper brings is also hard to beat, as is its gorgeous overall finish. It’s also made without heat-trapping foams that can leave you feeling sweaty as you sleep.
Things to Consider
While this topper doesn’t advertise a warranty, it does come with Boll & Branch’s general 30-day money-back guarantee. If you return your topper within 30 days of purchase, you can get a full refund in exchange. However, the brand does note that returns must be in original, saleable condition and still have their original tags and packaging. So it may not truly be possible to get your money back if you don’t love this product.
6. Sleep & Beyond MYMERINO Topper
| Organic Certifications | N/A |
| Material | 100% organic merino wool, organic cotton percale |
| Thickness | 1.5 inches |
| Firmness | Soft |
This popular Merino wool mattress topper is made of some of the softest material out there! It’s also a great choice for hot sleepers thanks to its temperature-regulating benefits. Stay toasty in the winter and sweat-free year-round with this breathable and cozy mattress topper.
Highlights
For a more cost-effective option, Sleep & Beyond’s wool mattress topper has a lot to offer. It seems durable enough to pay for itself, especially considering how much tossing and turning it can save you! It also comes in eco-friendly, reusable cotton packaging to cut down on unnecessary waste.
Things to Consider
While Sleep & Beyond lists this topper as organic, we couldn’t spot any specific certifications. This isn’t to say the materials aren’t organic, but detail-oriented shoppers may want to note this point. Otherwise, the brand’s five-year manufacturer warranty helps protect your investment for a decent amount of time.
Bonus For Budget Shoppers: Sleep & Beyond MYTOPPER
| Organic Certifications | N/A |
| Material | 100% organic merino wool, organic cotton percale |
| Thickness | 1.5 inches |
| Firmness | Soft |
Not ready or able to commit to a full-blown wool mattress topper? No problem. This washable wool-filled mattress topper offers similar benefits for a much friendlier price. As of 2023, these toppers begin at just $139. You can still take advantage of temperature regulation and soft, plush fibers without breaking the bank.
How to Find the Right Wool Mattress Topper
Clearly, there’s no shortage of topper options out there to choose from! With so many competing products in similar price ranges and with nearly identical perks, we know it’s tough to find the right fit. Consider these factors as you shop to make the best choice.
- Materials: Wool is, of course, the primary material you’ll want to look for. But depending on your preferences, you might also want to look out for cotton or wool blends. These additions may be favorable if you want something that offers the best of both worlds, but not if a 100% wool topper is your goal.
- Firmness: If you’re on the hunt for a topper to add support to your bed or make it softer, keep these goals at the front of your mind. Some toppers are great for adding pillowy cushioning, for instance, but others are firm and might make beds that are already too hard even worse. Likewise, choosing a topper that’s too flimsy won’t give you much relief from pain or discomfort.
- Certifications: If organic or sustainable materials are a priority for you, look for certifications like GOTS and GOLS. These indicate a product meets international standards for organic materials.
- Sustainability: The products that are kindest to the planet are usually made using traceable ingredients and manufactured in the U.S. They also tend to be more durable than the cheaper products you might find elsewhere.
Overall, the best wool mattress topper for you depends on your preferences and sleep style. We hope these picks lead you to the best match for your home!
