The Perfect Organic Mattress Protector for Your Home: 5 Top Picks

A mattress is arguably one of the largest and most important purchases you can make for a home. It – and your investment – deserves to be protected. But not all mattress protectors are made equal; an organic mattress protector can give you long-lasting results that are better and friendlier to the planet. 

Jump To Our Picks

Why Purchase an Organic Mattress Protector?

A sturdy mattress protector keeps the major investment that a mattress is safe from oils, sweat, spills, and other natural byproducts of wear and tear. 

But an organic mattress protector takes things a step further. These products are typically made using natural fibers that are free from harsh chemicals, pesticides, and herbicides. That means they’re far less likely to expose you to toxins or allergens.

In general, when you shop organic, you shop for the planet. Organic farming practices and regulations have been created with environmental protection in mind, ensuring that farmers use sustainable practices to support plant life and their surroundings.

Overall, if you want a product that’s kind to the planet, kind to your body, and kind to your wallet (no need to repurchase the same low-quality product over and over again!), organic mattress protectors may be for you. As more consumers become interested in shopping for products they can be proud of, the demand for sustainably produced home goods skyrockets.

Top 5 Organic Mattress Protectors: How We Chose

We scoured the web for the best organic mattress protectors available to recommend quality options from brands we trust. As we compiled this list, we looked at a few main factors to guide our judgment: 

  • Quality: We looked at details like materials used, manufacturing practices, longevity, and craftsmanship to assess item quality. 
  • Customer Experiences: We want to know that customers enjoy the product and don’t regret their purchase. We don’t want products that are “good enough” – we want picks that go above and beyond.
  • Brand: Our goal is to elevate brands that are working to make the world a better place. We paid attention to brand values and whether or not they’re upheld in product creation for each option below.
  • Value: Quality doesn’t always make a product worth it. We looked for options that offer true value – that is, they bring something unique or useful to the table on top of meeting our high overall standards.

We’re confident that these top picks tick the right boxes. All you have to decide which one is the best fit for your home!

Our Picks

All featured products are chosen at the discretion of the author and DGHQ editors. However, Do Good HQ may make a small affiliate commission if you click through and make a purchase.

1. PlushBeds Organic Mattress Protector

Organic CertificationsGOTS, USDA
MaterialCertified organic cotton
Fits Mattresses Up To15 inches thick

This organic, waterproof mattress protector from PlushBeds is a top choice thanks to its high-quality materials and sustainable production. As a family-owned company, PlushBeds takes care to design home products sourced and made locally. Soft cotton jersey joins a non-toxic and breathable waterproof underlayer to keep your mattress secure and comfortable.


There’s a lot more to love about this product than you might expect. We love that it’s not only made sustainably but also shipped in biodegradable packaging. This mattress protector is also machine washable, which makes regular cleaning a breeze. PlushBeds fans agree: this mattress protector is an investment that can last a lifetime.

Things to Consider

If you’re on the fence about the PlushBeds organic mattress protector, it’s important to consider that PlushBeds does not accept returns for bedding products due to sanitary reasons. There is a five-year warranty for this product that helps secure your investment, but it’s worth making sure this is the right fit for you before taking the splurge.

2. Avocado Organic Cotton Mattress Pad Protector

Organic CertificationsGOTS, GREENGUARD Gold, Climate Neutral, Fair Trade, Certified Vegan by Vegan Action
MaterialOrganic cotton, cotton fiber fill
Fits Mattresses Up To16 inches thick

Avocado is another brand based in California offering reliable organic and natural home goods, including mattresses, pillows, and bedding. The company is committed to being a trustworthy source for products created using environmentally conscious, sustainable, and ethical practices. This goal shines through in this organic mattress topper, which meets rigorous quality and organic standards and features a unique quilted finish.


We love that this topper is completely plastic-free; it makes it a great natural alternative to traditional waterproof options. It’s also a handmade product that’s durable enough to be machine washable.

Things to Consider

Try Avocado’s 100-day trial to see if this organic mattress protector is right for you. The product only comes with a one-year warranty, which is lower than other options on the market. Still, Avocado’s business practices and dedication to quality grant some peace of mind about this product’s longevity. 

3. Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Mattress Protector

Organic CertificationsGOTS, MADE SAFE, GREENGUARD Gold, Zero Toxics
MaterialOrganic cotton, polyurethane
Fits Mattresses Up To9 to 16 inches thick

Naturepedics gives competitors a run for their money with this organic waterproof mattress protector. Made with layers of oh-so-soft organic cotton jersey and a waterproof barrier, this product safely protects your mattress and helps you stay cool all night. Naturepedics is also part of 1% For the Planet, an organization whose members promise to donate at least one percent of their annual revenue to environmental causes.


You might expect a waterproof layer to contain sketchy ingredients like plastics or suspicious chemicals, but Naturepedics has created an environmentally-conscious system to keep your mattress dry and protected. Its polyurethane DrySleep Technology is GOTS-approved for safety so you can rest peacefully. As a bonus, the protector is also machine washable!

Things to Consider

Naturepedics offers a 30-day money-back guarantee and a one-year limited warranty for all mattress protector purchases, which is fairly standard. However, it’s worth noting that, unlike other options on our list, Naturepedics products are not manufactured domestically. They are, however, still made in a GOTS-certified organic facility.

4. Boll & Branch Mattress Protector

CertificationsGOTS, STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX, Asthma & Allergy Friendly
Material100% organic cotton
Fits Mattresses Up To15 inches deep

Boll & Branch is a trustworthy source for high-quality and natural mattresses and bedding products, including this beautiful mattress protector. Made from long-staple 100% organic cotton, this breathable protector keeps your mattress cozy and safe from stains or damage.


Boll & Branch always takes things to the next level with their product designs, and this protector is no exception. It’s crafted using long-staple cotton, which is known for its premium softness and silky texture. The materials used here may hold up better over time (which we expect, given its price tag!) than other picks.

Things to Consider

You can take advantage of Boll & Branch’s 30-day trial if you’d like to see how this mattress protector fits your home. Free returns are available during this window, as are full refunds. 

However, there is no advertised warranty associated with this product. All things considered, though, the price and make of this organic cotton mattress protector may make it worth it.

5. Happsy Organic Mattress Pad

Organic CertificationsGOLS, GOTS, MADE SAFE, GREENGUARD Gold, Zero Toxics, & more
MaterialOrganic cotton
Fits Mattresses Up To15 inches thick

With a name like Happsy, it’s hard to be mad at this organic cotton mattress pad, which effectively protects mattresses from allergens, spills, and other mishaps. It’s a simple, affordable solution that gets the job done right.


The organic cotton jersey used in this waterproof protector is flexible and lightweight enough to easily stretch over your bed. Some happy shoppers claim Happsy matches the quality of competing brands for a far lower price. Starting at just $79, this protector is certainly hard to beat!

Things to Consider

Happsy offers a 120-night trial for their mattresses and other products, so it’s safe to assume the same applies to this mattress protector. The brand undoubtedly blows the rest out of the water with its 20-year warranty, though it’s tough to tell if this only applies to mattress purchases or all products. 

Next Best Option: Parachute Cotton Mattress Protector

Organic mattress protectors can be pricey, but they’re not the only sustainable and high-quality options out there. For the budget-conscious shopper, we recommend the Parachute Cotton Mattress Protector.

Material100% cotton
Thickness3 inches
Fits Mattresses Up To16 inches thick

While it’s not made from organic materials, this plush and soft mattress protector is created using high-quality cotton fabric and fill. It’s a great alternative if you want something that’s still durable but more approachable.

How to Find the Right Organic Mattress Protector

Companies are constantly competing to grab your attention with the hottest new products, which can make it hard to know where to zoom in. After all, what the “best” product on the market is really just depends on your preferences.

You can use these essential factors to help you select the organic mattress protector that makes sense for your budget and needs. 

  • Materials: You may have noticed that many organic mattress protectors are made from organic cotton, but this isn’t the only material you can choose from. You might decide to opt for an organic wool mattress protector, for instance, if you’d like something fluffier and warmer. Likewise, if you want a waterproof protector, make sure you choose one with at least one layer that can safeguard against moisture.
  • Organic Certifications: If finding an organic protector is your goal, it’s vital to look for certifications that prove a product is up to standard. Look for GOTS and GOLS as indicators that a product’s materials meet international expectations. Other certifications, like GREENGUARD Gold, show that a product has been made using environmentally friendly practices.
  • Size: Most protectors fit mattresses up to 15 or 16 inches deep, which includes most standard sizes out there. But if you have an especially thin or thick mattress, make sure your potential protector will be up to the task of staying in place.
  • Manufacturing Practices: While not all organic products are made using the same environmental or labor standards, many of them are. If sustainability and traceable supply chains are important to you, count on companies that have proven their commitment to these efforts.

With these tips and recommendations in mind, you have what you need to find your dream organic mattress topper. We wish you good luck on your hunt – and a great night’s rest!

Image by Pexels from Pixabay

About The Author

Scroll to Top